Quote Originally Posted by mattusss View Post
Seeing something that is not close to genuine specifications, such as an E caseback on a F model Panerai, isn't a "I think the seller is a scammer" type of post or PM a member should consider. Not every replica listed for sale is going to be a $1,500 replica, and therefore, the shortcomings of a watch should not be discussed, unless the seller advertises it as being "perfect".
That's a gray area that I'd like some clarification (maybe a few use cases on the guidelines)

If somebody lists an ultimate and you notice the caseback, case, CG, etc. are not ultimate do you call it?

Or if they are selling a $200 rep and asking $350 with clever marketing?

Or when somebody asks a question about lume, or movement and the seller is evasive or untruthful with the answer?